Once
an adult is convicted of a felony, that person is always and forever a “felon” for the rest of his or her life. In
Texas, there is no way to reduce the impact of the permanent label “felon”. It is on the person’s criminal record
forever, and most felony conviction records are available to the public on the internet.
Indirect or collateral
consequences of felony punishment in Texas extend deep into the life of the individual and the community, and
have wide ranging ramifications. For most felons, time in prison begins a life-long series of punishments.
While it might seem reasonable for certain violent felons to be punished in all of these
ways for the rest of their lives, the punishments are so permanent and harmful that as a society we must closely
examine who we are subjecting to these policies.
Legal barriers and roadblocks that face felons in Texas
severely limit access to all of life’s most fundamental necessities – food,
clothing, shelter, employment and education.
1. Civil Rights
“Equal rights”
does not apply to convicted felons in Texas. According to the Texas Constitution, felons are
not equal under Texas law. The law ensures a felon can never exercise many of the
rights that other people have to participate in our democratic government or access any degree of political
power.
A felon in Texas can never
hold a public elective office. A felon can not serve on a jury or a grand jury in Texas. If a felon is ever
a witness in a Texas courtroom, the fact that they are a felon is automatically admissible as evidence in court. A felon can
not legally protect a family member’s estate by acting as an executor or administrator of an estate in probate court.
2. Housing
In determining eligibility
for public housing, federal law gives local public housing agencies the ability to deny housing to virtually
anyone with a criminal background. Each local public housing agency sets its own policy about whether it will ban felons
from public housing. Local housing authorities can consider the individual circumstances and history of applicants if that
is their policy. They can decide whether to consider arrests that have not resulted in a conviction in eviction proceedings.
They can determine how long to deny housing assistance to people with criminal records. They can decide what, if
anything, qualifies as rehabilitation for the purpose of lifting the bar to public housing.
Private landlords
can, and usually do, refuse to rent to felons. Even felons raising children are usually limited to the worst part
of town to find an apartment because no other landlord will rent to them. No matter how long or how hard a felon works
to improve his or her life, and no matter how many children depend on the felon for support, many felons must raise their
family in substandard housing because of the label “felon”.
3. Employment
Prison inmates who
learn marketable job skills in prison return there less than half as often as inmates who do not. Most people agree
that career-oriented employment is key to long-term positive change.
Texas does not prohibit
discrimination by employers based on a criminal record. Employers in Texas usually ask job applicants about arrests
and convictions, and almost always refuse to employ felons regardless of individual circumstance or business necessity.
A felon who has been convicted of a drug crime can be an attorney,
but not a notary public. And a felon
can get permission to be a licensed physician, but not a physician’s assistant. Clearly, the legal bans on employing a felon in Texas are irrational.
As an additional
barrier to employment, Texas has over 100 state laws that forbid a felon working certain types of jobs. Just a few
employment opportunities legally banned for felons in Texas are:
• Labor union officer
or labor organizer,
• Pesticide applicator
(ineligible for 5 years),
• Person who issues parking
tickets for disabled parking spaces,
• Court interpreter,
• Meat and poultry inspection
service,
• Auctioneer,
• Athletic trainer (at
the discretion of the licensing agency),
• Insurance agent, counselor,
or adjustor (discretion of agency),
• Interior designer (discretion
of agency),
• Acupuncturist (discretion
of agency),
• Midwife (discretion
of agency),
• Mortgage broker,
• Distributor or manufacturer
of medical devices (discretion of agency),
• Speech – Language
pathologist (discretion of agency),
• Hearing aid fitter
or distributor (discretion of agency),
• Physical therapist
(discretion of agency),
• Dental hygienist (discretion
of agency),
• Marriage or family
counselor,
• Monitor or aid on a
school bus,
• Registered nurse (discretion
of agency),
• Chiropractor (discretion
of agency),
• Physician assistant,
• Psychologist,
• Private security detection
device salesperson,
• Bingo worker, supply
manufacturer or distributor, or service provider (ineligible for 10 years),
• Coin-operated machine
business license,
• Business license holder,
• Vehicle storage facility
operator (ineligible for 3 years).
Laws banning felons
from doing certain jobs in Texas do not appear to be consistent or logical. Some are prohibited only for a certain
number of years while others can be decided at the discretion of a board or commission based on personal circumstances.
Whether or not the legal bans on felon employment in Texas make sense, they are very real barriers to success.
Texas should revisit
the list of banned jobs so that felons are only excluded for reasons of business necessity. In addition, Texas
should offer a certificate of rehabilitation which would lift the bar to employment for a felon who obtains one. At
this time, six other states (Arizona, California, Illinois, Nevada, New Jersey and New York) offer such
an opportunity to felons.
4. Education
Federal and state
law discourages felons from obtaining higher education. Federal law states that students convicted of a drug-related
offense are ineligible for grants, loans and work assistance. This federal barrier cannot be altered by the
states. No other class of offense, including violent offenses, sex offenses, repeat offenses, or
alcohol-related offenses, results in the automatic denial of education financial aid eligibility.
Felons in Texas
can not receive most state-based higher education financial aid including prepaid higher education tuition
scholarships. Felons are not eligible for a Toward Excellence, Access & Success (TEXAS) grant or a TEXAS
grant II for public, private or two-year institutions of higher education.
5. Food and necessities.
The 1996 federal
welfare law prohibits anyone convicted of a drug-related felony from receiving federally funded
food stamps and cash assistance(also known as TANF - Temporary Assistance for Needy Families). This is a lifetime ban--
even if someone has completed his or her sentence, overcome an addiction, been employed but got laid off, or earned
a certificate of rehabilitation.
States can maintain
the federal lifetime ban on cash assistance and food stamps, but they also have the option of passing
legislation to limit the ban or eliminate it altogether. Texas has adopted the federal drug felon ban on public
assistance. No person
in Texas who receives a felony drug conviction after 1996 is eligible to receive Temporary Assistance for
Needy Families or food stamps.
“Effective preparation of prison inmates to succeed in the outside
world must become one of the highest priorities
of both legislative policy makers and corrections professionals alike. We must fully fund and integrate current re-entry programs into a seamless re-entry initiative
which begins with cognitive behavior
training, offers correctional industries job training and certification in recognized work skills, provides in-prison drug and alcohol treatment, technical
work and life skills training.”
Quote from Representative
Ray Allen, Chairman of the Corrections Committee in the Texas House of Representatives, Effective Corrections
Requires More Than Tough Prisons, American Legislative Exchange Council Issue Analysis, April 2004.