Change is constant – the only question
is the direction of the change. If Texas does not change
its current policies, then the change will be the construction
of thousands and thousands of new prison beds. Politicians
who want to be tough on crime must realize that being tough
means doing "what works" to change criminal behavior.
TX prison spending increased 268% in the 90's, faster than health care or education.
Texas has added over 4,000 new prison beds
since the 2003 legislative session, and they are
full. If policies do not change, Texas is
expected to need 2,000 additional prison beds every
year. That means Texas can either start building thousands
of new prison beds each year, which will cost millions
of dollars, or we can change our criminal sentencing policies
to better protect the public safety.
Our Texas Legislature has direct control
over who goes to Texas prison and for how long –
they enact our state sentencing laws. Our Governor must
agree anytime the Legislature changes state sentencing
laws. The Texas Legislature defines
which behaviors are crimes, and the penalty range for
each crime. They determine which crimes are felonies and
which crimes are misdemeanors.
A felony conviction can result in a sentence to prison, and cause the person to have life long status as a "felon" with all of the consequences
of that label. A misdemeanor conviction, on the
other hand, is punishable by fines or time in the county jail and fewer collateral consequences result from the conviction. Prison is reserved for felons only.
Texas Department of Criminal Justice director
Gary Johnson testified to the Senate Criminal Justice
Committee the agency must spend 90% of its budget
on prison beds due to "front end pressure." That
means that there are so many felons entering the
prison, and the prison has a legal duty to hold
them inside due to long sentences, that TDCJ has
no choice – it must spend 90% of its budget on prison beds, leaving almost no money available for alternatives to incarceration and "what works".
Texas prison sentences are double the national
average.
The national average was just over 5 years
in 1996, while the average Texas prison sentence
was 9.5 years. 70% of admissions to Texas prison
each year are for nonviolent crimes.
Nearly half of Texas’ 15,000 state
jail felony prisoners are serving time for drug
convictions involving less than one gram. Moving this offender to the misdemeanor level would save $73 million a year in prison costs – money better invested in education, families,
and alternatives that work.
In 2003, three members of the Texas House of Representatives,
Chairman Harold Dutton, Chairman Ron Wilson, and Representative Jack Stick filed House Bill 2316, a serious attempt
to decrease some of our low-level nonviolent felony penalties. That bill, if it had passed into law, was predicted to save Texas more than $58 million during the 2004/2005
biennium and more than $461 million during the 2006/2007 biennium
in prison costs. We must revisit this type of reform for the sake of protecting our families – Texas needs those precious tax dollars for programs that improve our communities.
Sadly, each time the Texas Legislature meets it passes numerous new criminal penalty enhancements, increasing specific criminal penalties. It has been said that a new felony is the easiest law to pass in Texas. Few people will oppose a new criminal penalty enhancement, because they are afraid it will look like they approve of the conduct.
For instance, Texas passed a new law in 2003
that increased the criminal penalty for assault
if the person assaults a sports official. Even though
assault is already a crime, people were afraid that
if they opposed the new law it might seem like they
were in favor of assaulting sports officials. We have to work smarter than that. Texas should refuse to pass any new criminal penalty enhancements until the prison crisis is solved.
Senator Whitmire pledged that he will not allow any new penalty enhancements to pass in to law in 2005. Senator Whitmire,
Chairman of the Criminal Justice Committee in the Texas
Senate, made his pledge at the TDCJ Community Justice
Assistance Division Sentencing Conference in the spring
of 2004. Support for intelligent elected officials like
Chairman Whitmire is essential.
Research clearly shows that the old "tough on crime" policies do not
stop crime. Elected officials who try to act "tough on crime" with the old rhetoric and old ideas should be politely educated
about "what works". If an elected official is serious about stopping crime, he or she has no choice but to support solutions
that work to reduce crime.