Effective Solutions for the Texas Criminal Justice System

July 24, 2005 Houston Chronicle "County does little to ease jail crowding"
Home | Solutions | F.A.Q.s | At the Legislature | In the News | Library | Events

County does little to ease jail crowding
 
Some inmates, guards complain of dangers to health and safety

By STEVE MCVICKER and BILL MURPHY

Harris County officials were warned almost two years ago of a looming explosion in the county jail population, but still have taken little or no action.

 
Despite the ominous September 2003 forecast in a Sam Houston State University report, nine months before a state watchdog agency first decertified the jail because of crowding, one department head concedes that county leaders have done little more than monitor the problem.

"We've been watching it and looking at it," Budget Officer Dick Raycraft said.
 
Indeed, rather than help deal with the problem by putting more deputies to work in the jail, county officials in recent years have been diverting officers to patrol duty, Raycraft said.

 
"It was a collaborative decision by the sheriff and the Commissioners Court," he said.

 
The Texas Commission on Jail Standards, which last month decertified the county jail for the second year in a row, now says jail crowding has created dangerous and unsanitary conditions.

Inmates and guards who spoke to the Houston Chronicle last week described those conditions in detail.

 
Two veteran jailers, independently of each other, described the jail system as ripe for violence.

 
And, they say, inmates already are suffering from staphylococcus infections.

Both jailers contacted the Chronicle after seeing the newspaper's July 16 report on the jail's decertification.

The state jail commission has warned that decertification can expose the county to greater civil liability. The panel also has the
power, as a last resort, to shut the jail.

 
Speaking on the condition of anonymity, the two jailers charged that Sheriff's Office officials sometimes hid inmates from state inspectors.

"They played a game of musical inmates," said one jailer, who also is a deputy sheriff. "They would take them from one
building to another through the tunnel system."

 
The downtown jail system consists of main buildings at 1200 Baker and 701 N. San Jacinto, and a smaller facility at 1307 Baker. A tunnel connects the two larger jails.

 
After the inspectors left, the deputy said, the inmates were crammed back into units that already were fully occupied, a practice he called "sardining."

The jail commission decertified the county lockup after inspectors found in June almost 1,300 of its more than 9,000 inmates
sleeping on mattresses on concrete floors, some next to toilets.

 
Hiding inmates denied

Chief Deputy Mike Smith, who oversees jail operations, denied that any inmates have been concealed from inspectors and
said no inmates are going without mattresses.

 
He also said he is unaware of any widespread staph outbreak.

"You know, we have to work here, too," he said.

 
Staph bacteria commonly cause minor skin infections, but also can cause infections in the blood, bones and lungs.

 
Smith said the Sheriff's Office is working on ways to ease the crowding. He said 450 inmates who require less supervision were moved Saturday to lower-level security housing adjacent to the two main jails. That shift will still leave 1,200 to 1,400 inmates sleeping on the floor, Smith said.

The crowding resulted from a shortage of guards.

According to the commission report, large sections of the jail have been closed because of understaffing while other areas are
populated beyond capacity.

County officials have placed much of the blame on what they say is a backlog of inmates awaiting transfer to state prisons.
 
However, the Texas Department of Criminal Justice insists it is accepting all prison-ready inmates well within the 45 days required by state law.

According to Raycraft, Harris County pays $12,000 a year to Charles M. Friel, a professor at Sam Houston State's College of
Criminal Justice, to forecast trends in law enforcement each quarter. In a report presented to Commissioners Court in September 2003, Friel predicted that the county jail population "could rise to 8,600 by the end of July 2004, a 12-month increase of 15 percent."

Jail policies blamed

Additionally, while noting that a portion of the backlog consists of prison-ready inmates and parole violators, the report by Friel
also pointed to the policies of Harris County's criminal justice system as a large reason for the increase in inmates.
Specifically, he cited the growing numbers of defendants unable to post bail while awaiting trial, as well as nonviolent offenders given jail time instead of alternative sentencing.

In subsequent reports, Friel has continued to warn the county about the expanding jail population.

When fully staffed, the three facilities have an official capacity of 9,383 inmates, according to commission records. Because of
the guard shortage, however, jail officials had closed two floors at 1200 Baker and parts at 1307 Baker at the time of the jail commission's inspection last month.

Overall, space for 1,853 inmates was not in use because of understaffing, the commission reported.

At the same time, the North San Jacinto jail was almost 700 inmates over capacity.

As of Friday, the total jail population was about 9,100, sheriff's officials reported. Almost 1,000 were state-jail felons sentenced
to serve their time in the county jail, Smith said. Almost 3,000 others have not been able to make bail and are awaiting trial.

"So should we have a different bonding structure and get a few more of these people out of here?" Smith asked. " I can't
answer that by myself and I can't control that. But, you know, guess who gets them?"

Panel has yet to meet

After commissioners received Friel's report in 2003, Raycraft said the county would reconvene its Criminal Justice Committee.
 
Made up of representatives from Commissioners Court and each division of the county criminal justice system, the committee was created in response to a jail-crowding lawsuit that kept the county jail under a federal judge's control for 23 years, ending in 1995.

However, almost two years after Friel's report, the committee has yet to meet. Raycraft said a meeting is planned for Friday.

As for the cost of resolving the problem, Raycraft estimated that if, for example, 150 new guards are needed, it would cost
about $7 million.

Smith said Friday that the latest projections he has seen put the number of new jailers needed at almost 300.

But before that issue is settled, the committee will explore ways to reduce the number of inmates, Raycraft said.

Meanwhile, guards and inmates alike have voiced concerns about health problems, especially staph infections.

One civilian jailer claimed last week to have seen as many as 134 inmates crowded into a space designed for 94. Some
inmates sleep on the floor near toilets, he said, and some have no mattresses or blankets.

Inmates sometimes go a week without a change of uniform, the jailer said, and some never receive shower shoes or hygiene
kits. He also said he has seen inmates with sores as large as "the top of a soft drink can" from staph infections.

He added that most jailers are slow to allow inmates to obtain treatment in the infirmary.

"If you do, you're branded an inmate-lover," the jailer said.

Inmate tells of illnesses

Current and former inmates say crowding has led to increased violence among inmates, frequent arguments over toilet paper,
food and other items, and the spread of disease.

An inmate who asked not to be identified because he fears retaliation said he contracted a staph infection this month, but jail
personnel ignored his requests for medical treatment.

The inmate said his infection started with a bump on a leg, but it spread because he didn't get treatment, leading to four more
infections.

Detention officers, he said, told him doctors would see him only if an infection ruptured. He said he lied on a medical form,
claiming he had a ruptured boil.

The inmate said he agreed to pay the standard $16 fee to be examined, but the doctor refused to treat him because he didn't
have a rupture.

He said he wonders whether he contracted the illness because he lives in a dormitory-style area at 701 N. San Jacinto that is
designed for 24, but often houses 42 or more. Some inmates sleep on mats on the floor near toilets, he said.

''There are two ways I could have gotten it," he said. "(The toilets) kept overflowing onto the floor, but I think it's because of the
clothes. They aren't washing them good enough."

Two others in his facility also have come down with staph, he said.

County officials are scheduled to explain to the state jail commission on Aug. 4 why, after the jail was decertified more than a
year ago, the problem remains uncorrected.
 
HARRIS COUNTY JAIL COMPLEX
 
1200 Baker: Opened January 2003 with 603,000 square feet. Houses Sheriff's Office and has beds for 96 mental health patients. The medical division, with 124 beds, has a "negative air flow" system to combat transmission of airborne illnesses; the fourth floor houses female prisoners; and the sixth floor houses a vocational law library.

1307 Baker: Built in 1998, with an addition in 2001. Designed as a "semi-direct observation" facility where the staff monitors
inmates 24 hours a day. Originally built for the Texas prison system, now leased by the Sheriff's Office.

701 N. San Jacinto: Opened in 1991. Originally built in the 1920s as a five-story cold-storage warehouse. Two floors were
added when it was renovated to be a jail.

Source: Harris County Sheriff's Office and Texas Commission on Jail Standards