Effective Solutions for the Texas Criminal Justice System

May 23, 2003 Quorum Report "Taylor: ACLU praises Keel for maneuver on Tulia bill"
Home | Solutions | F.A.Q.s | At the Legislature | In the News | Library | Events
Taylor: ACLU praises Keel for maneuver on Tulia bill
Sent to Local and Consent

ACLU Texas Executive Director Will Harrell is calling Rep. Terry Keel (R-Austin) a "legislative genius" after he resurrected the bill that would free the Tulia 13.

Senate Bill 1948, by Sen. John Whitmire (D-Houston), was jammed up behind Senate Bill 14, the big insurance reform bill that the House has been debating for the past three days.

Realizing his bill was in real danger, Keel, chairman of the House Criminal Jurisprudence Committee, asked for a motion to suspend House rules so that his committee could meet to revisit SB 1948.

At a hastily arranged hearing in the Speaker’s press room, the committee voted unanimously to send Whitmire’s bill to the House Local and Consent Committee.

Now, Harrell and other supporters of the Tulia bill are hard at work lobbying Local and Consent Committee members. Whitmire’s bill will permit a Swisher County judge to release the Tulia 13 from prison on bond while the Court of Criminal Appeals ponders the case. Harrell said Gov. Rick Perry supports the bill.

"We feel truly vindicated after three years of screaming about the injustice of Tulia," said a delighted Harrell.

"Rep. Keel is a legislative genius. As a former law enforcement officer he knows what happened in the Tulia case. He was not going to sit by and let justice for the Tulia 13 die in calendars. I think he showed extraordinary legislative prowess to suspend House rules and find the last possible procedural mechanism available."

Harrell was disappointed, however, that Senate Bill 515, by Sen. Juan "Chuy" Hinojosa (D-McAllen), looked like it was dying on the Senate Intent Calendar. Known as the Tulia Corroboration Bill, the bill would instruct juries not to convict on the basis of the uncorroborated evidence of a peace officer’s testimony. Harrell said it was ironic that Hinojosa had 13 votes in the Senate.

The author of the bill was more sanguine.

"You cannot change bureaucratic institutions overnight," Hinojosa said. "We have made great strides over the past two sessions with major criminal justice legislation, such as the DNA bill, and indigent defense. Law enforcement agencies are learning from scandals like Tulia."

May 23, 2003 by Harvey Kronberg, www.quorumreport.com

.